Enviornment clearance for Lafarge cement plant revoked in Himachal

Shimla: In a significant shot in the arm of the enviornment activists in the state, the National Environment Appellate Authority (NEAA) revoked the environment clearance granted to cement maker Lafarge India for its greenfield project in Alsindi in Mandi district of Himachal Pradesh.

lafargeThe NEAA judgment came after a one-man team, comprising NEAA Cairman J.C. Kala, visited the Lafarge’ plant site on June 23 and heard grievances of the local people facing displacement.

The NEAA judgment noted that the environment and forests ministry while granting environment clearance June 8, 2009, ignored the fact that the project would affect the wildlife of the Majathal Wildlife Sanctuary that is located less than five km from the project site.

The Monday order of the NEAA, an appeals body created by an Act of Parliament, said: ‘The authority is convinced that on environmental and social considerations it is neither desirable to mine Telehan village nor put up cement plant at Ghanger’.

The appeals body’s order went on to criticize the ministry of environment and forests, and the expert appraisal committee, which analyses the environment impact assessment, or EIA, and forwards it recommendations for a final decision, for not having correctly assessed the impact of the project on land, water and air, and failing to appreciate its effects on the livelihood of the people in the area.

According to the appellate body, on its site visit, it observed that there was total opposition to the mine from villagers of Talehan village. Its order said that the villagers’ dependence is on agriculture and livestock, and that Lafarge’s claim that the mining area is not cultivable is untrue. NEAA also said that while the company claimed it would secure the consent of at least 70% of the households in the area, Lafarge has admitted that it has, as of date, acquired the consent of only 16 of 381 landowners.

Lafarge’s statement reiterated several points made in EIA: that a majority of the people living within a 10km radius of the project do not depend on agriculture for their livelihood, and that the plant and mine are to come up on uncultivable land.

Lafarge received its clearance on June 8, 2009 following an inspection by the ministry on May 5 the same year.

A Lafarge statement released on Monday said that NEAA has set aside the clearance, based on certain observations of the sole member of the tribunal and that the appellate authority has not found any irregularities or violations committed by the company.

“The company is in the process of examining the order and will decide on the future course of action soon,” it added.

A Lafarge executive added that the company has already tried to minimize its environmental footprint. Anurag Kak, senior vice-president at Lafarge who is in charge of the Himachal project said, ‘We have tried to reduce the actual mining area considerably. We have been awarded 800 ha, of which about 325 ha will be mined. So relocation is only for one village and there is some cultivation in the mining area. The projected capital cost is Rs. 1,000 crore.’

Environmentalists Manshi Asher and Prakash Bhandari, who are fighting for the rights of the people to be affected by the project, told reporters that the NEAA judgment showed that ‘the dispossession, impoverishment and trauma attached to displacement have neither been captured by the environment impact assessment nor appreciated by the expert appraisal committee or the state government.

In March 2007, Lafarge India had signed a memorandum of understanding with the government of Himachal Pradesh to set up the cement manufacturing facility at Alsindi near Karsog and undertake mining of 3 million tons per annum of limestone.

Manshi Asher’s note on Lafarge India’s project can be read here.

Related Posts with Thumbnails

One Response to "Enviornment clearance for Lafarge cement plant revoked in Himachal"

  1. Anil   December 29, 2010 at 3:09 am

    I am glad to see that justice has finally been delivered and it’s a very big win not only for the pepople to HP but to the environment too. I am really disappointed to know that the leaders of state goverment and/or Central goverment have become so corrupt that they don’t see the impact of putting a cement plant. These leaders or whosoever is involved in the initial appraisals are blinded by the greed for making money that they just ignore the fact that a beautiful state like himachal will no longer be known for its climate. We then talk about how beautiful foreign countries are; well firstly we need to accept India and its states have much more beautiful places to see and admire than the whole world may have; but we Indians are ignorant and run towards “Imported”.
    I can keep going on pointing out the greed to us (Indians) and our leaders but that will drift me from the point I have here to make:

    We have been blessed to live in such a beautiful country (India) and its surroundings (States) and must take a Oath of making it’s/their future clean and green.
    I am very thankful to Mr. J.C Kala and all others involved in revoking clearance for this project.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.